Belkin Dual-Fit Armband for iPod nano 4G (Black)

This thing works well. The only issue, as I'm sure people have stated, is that it's problematic when trying to actually operate the ipod. Previously I would just take out the ipod to change the volume or switch a song or playlist. The product overall, after going through some armbands, is good. What you can do, which my brilliant boyfriend figured out, take an exacto knife and cut out the area around the ipod click wheel. Works awesome! After that... it's perfect.

I gave this item as a gift and the receiver was very happy with it, so I guess it was a good choice.

My arm radius might be 7" around (like, the doctor usually uses a child cuff when taking my blood pressure.) Amazingly, this product actually fit my arms. I really like how comfortable and easy it is to use. The only downside is the funky plastic used to product the iPod's front; it's plastic that can get funky easily - especially at the gym. Also, the fabric is loose enough that it doesn't stay aligned with the holes for the buttons/ports on the top and bottom. Otherwise, it is a sound product.

When my iPod Shuffle finally died I looked to replace it with another but the new Shuffle has the volume control on the cord which would not work for me. I ended up ordering a 16GB Nano 4G. I typically run five days a week and two to three of those will be with music. I originally ordered the Belkin armband and although it had some nice features, the top loading design allowed sweat from the upper arm to flow right into it and even simple humidity would let moisture accumulate. Did a long run and there was actually condensation forming inside the screen of my new iPod. Additionally, it seemed to be constructed with cheap materials.

I purchsed the Insport armband case and the neoprene is thicker. Although the exterior was wet after running 20 miles, the iPod was completely dry. It also loads from the bottom which concerned me at first because I was worried about the player sliding out but the elastic as well as the tension when strapped to the arm held it in securely. The only other opening is a small hole at the top for access to the hold switch. I'm 5'11, 175 pounds and I had no problem fitting this around my bicep. I'm a runner though, not a bodybuilder so if you have truly huge arms, this may not work

Belkin
Pros: Lighter weight, one slot for storing excess headphone cord and one on the inside surface for a cash or small key (you will not be able to fit any car key that has electronic components but a house key will fit).
Cons: The top loading design does not keep the player dry. The plastic over the face of the click wheel is too thick for adjusting the volume.

Incase
Pros: Thicker material to protect the iPod. the plastic is thinner and even while running I can adjust the volume.
Cons: The hole for the hold switch is not necessary and could potentially let water enter if it begins to rain. For the average amount of sweat though it does fine. The strap is oriented to the front of your arm if worn on the left side. Since I'm right handed this is how I wear it which leaves the excess strap on the inside of the arm which could be distracting. Nothing major though. My biggest complaint is the price. At almost $30, it's way more than the $12 I paid for the belkin. For the peace of mind of not worrying about moisture, it is worth it.

I really enjoy using this armband! In fact, I bought one about 9 months ago, and I just bought two more just in case they stop selling the product. I find most armbands shift/move around when lifting weights or running. This armband stays in place. I use this armband at least 4-5 days a week while doing weights and running (typically avg. 15 miles a week). I've owned the first armband for about 9 months now and it's starting to show some wear and tear. I wash mine in the wash machine once a week. I like the small pocket behind the ipod to store a key or cash. There is also a very small pocket used to store the Nike+ receiver (at least that's what I use if for.) Lastly, it has small access slits at the bottom to plug in the headphones jack and Nike+ receiver. I would buy this armband again and would highly recommend this armband! Note - I have noticed SMALL amounts of condensation build up (from sweat) behind the plastic after long runs, but I try and remove the Ipod from the armband as soon as I can after my long runs.